Crochet Pattern Testing

Crochet Pattern Testing Overview

Let’s begin by explaining, briefly, what crochet pattern testing is and then going over it in a bit more detail. Also, I think it would be interesting to explore the subject from both the designer’s and tester’s perspectives, so that’s what I’m going to do! Hopefully, I have insight into both because I have tested a fair few crochet patterns over the years, and I am also a crochet designer.

In a nutshell, crochet pattern testing is checking to see if an unpublished crochet pattern works. A group of testers will follow a draft pattern while they each make the finished item. As they follow along, they make sure the pattern makes sense and produces a finished crochet item as the designer intended. They then provide feedback to the designer about the experience and provide polite, constructive criticism.

Let’s be clear from the start, pattern testing is not the same as technical editing! There should be no obligation to fine-tooth comb anything.

Crochet Pattern Testing Vs Tech Editing

On social media platforms, I often find myself reading discussions about crochet pattern testing. There are many honest opinions that are shared, and some folks seem to think that it should involve grammar checks, number checking (maths, stitch counts), pattern formatting, and more. Actually, this should have already been looked at by a technical editor before any tester gets their hands on an unpublished pattern draft.

Tech editing is a paid service carried out by an experienced, trained editor who is a whizz at number crunching and has a keen eye for detail. The advice they can offer is invaluable, and if you are a crochet designer, you should be using their services for nearly all of your patterns.

With that attention to detail, most errors and formatting styles will have been ironed out. It is not for the pattern tester to do any of this, but the odd thing escapes those eagle eyes, and an edit doesn’t show what a final product will look like when made by different hands.

Sadly, most independent designers don’t have a budget to pay for testing and they rely on the kindness of volunteer crocheters who are happy and willing to help.

Why Do We Need Crochet Pattern Testing?

Making sure crochet patterns are clear, succinct and do what they say they do is super important. We’re all human, and even a super amazing designer with awesome tech editing skills can miss a typo or two. Crochet pattern testing helps with that.

To test is to help out fellow crafters in the yarny community. Tests often have a community focus where there are chat groups for testers to convene, ask questions and share their making experiences. I’ve made many friends by taking part in these group chats. It’s also a great way to gain experience and improve crochet skills.

A good crochet pattern test should be mutually beneficial. A designer gets the chance to find out if their new pattern can be understood by real makers. A tester gets an exclusive glance at the design process. Whether they want to become designers themselves or just have the desire to support the work of a small creative business, it should be a positive experience.

The Dark Side of Crochet Pattern Testing

It would be remiss of me to ignore the negative side of pattern testing for crochet. This is kind of what made me want to write about it in the first place. Various online threads of debate discuss both the good and the bad. Obviously, I want to focus on the good bits, but there is a dark side to this topic too.

Both, testers and designers can be left with a bitter taste from a crappy pattern testing experience. I’ve learned that pattern testers can be greatly exploited and pushed beyond reasonable expectations. For example, there are demands for sharing multiple photos, Reels and Stories on social media to “market” a pattern on behalf of a designer. Whilst yes, it is a boon if this happens, a designer should never push this as an essential because it isn’t why patterns are tested.

I know from my own ventures into running testing groups that testers will join to take a pattern and disappear from the group. For me, the most stressful element about a new pattern is the testing phase. I worry constantly about whether everyone is OK. I had one experience last year that I never wish to repeat, where one by one, testers disappeared until it felt like I was talking to no one. It’s a long story that I can’t tell without name dropping a brand that’s much larger than my one-woman band… However, from that time, I also learned that some folks in the world have hearts of gold.

I’ll go over some of these thoughts in more detail throughout the post as well.

Communication is Key!

Unfortunately, as I’ve mentioned, pattern testing can lead to animosity on both sides; the best way to avoid this is to know exactly what to expect.

If in doubt, have the confidence to ask questions. It’s super important that both parties engage regularly and check-in.

As a tester, if you’re struggling, keep in touch to let the designer know there’ll be delays, or if you have to withdraw from the test don’t be afraid to say so. A decent, experienced designer will have factored this into the test and not be reliant on one person. But it is super helpful to let the designer know you can’t complete it, as crochet pattern testing can be an anxious time. It’s not an excuse for rudeness from anyone!

Designers need to be well prepared to update testers regularly. Answer questions promptly and don’t get offended if someone points out that things aren’t clear. This is the point of testing! Listen to what your testers are telling you. If they’re querying what could be an error, check it, don’t dismiss it.

Testing peeps, don’t make assumptions about a pattern, please don’t guess; this is the perfect opportunity to get the designer’s attention. Ask the questions; get clarification.

How Do You Become a Pattern Tester?

There are a few different ways to become a crochet pattern tester. I haven’t tried them all. Each way of finding a testing group will be different. You will find that each designer has a preferred approach.

Instagram – Designers will put out a call for testers by way of a post on the IG grid or on Stories. This is normally how I do it. I create a simple form/questionnaire on Google Drive. Interested crocheters can click on a link to accurately complete the form. This way, I can export all the data into a snazzy spreadsheet; it’s a neat way to keep track of everyone so no one gets missed.

Ravelry Testing Pool – I used this a few years ago with mixed results. There are rules in place, and people are vocal if you don’t follow those rules. That’s OK, there are other similar forums and being respectful is paramount.

Yarn Pond – This is a one-stop shop for pattern testing and testers. Yarnpond has been around a long time, too. I’ve not gone down this path. The website has loads of info, should you be intrigued.

Designers’ List – Many designers (I’m not one of them) keep a list of pattern testers who are keen to be contacted whenever that designer has a new pattern on the horizon. I like this idea very much. However, I feel uncomfortable directly asking individuals if they can take the time to test.

Facebook Groups – Crochet is BIG on Facebook, you are definitely spoilt for choice with all the different pages and posts. Search for testing groups to see if there is one that suits your style.

Requirements for Being a Crochet Tester

Again, for testing crochet patterns, requirements will vary depending on what the designer is looking for with their crochet pattern testers. Let’s break it down.

Crochet Skills Level/Experience

If you have never been a crochet pattern tester before, don’t let your perceived skill level put you off. It is in the designer’s best interest to choose a group of testers who represent all abilities because it’s a truer reflection of those who will want to buy the pattern.

Having said that, perhaps it’s not a good idea to sign up for an advanced and mega complicated sweater test if you have never made a garment before… Be realistic but don’t be put off either. Gen up with these Crochet Tips & Tricks.

Do You Have Time for Crochet Pattern Testing?

Don’t overcommit or overstretch yourself; it’s stressful, and testing should be fun. No one wants you to get anxiety from crochet pattern testing. If you have other commitments, think about the deadline. Is it achievable for you?

Confidence & Willingness to Partake

There are usually some social elements to pattern testing. Not always, but increasingly, tests take place in group chats so that testers can write/talk to one another, share ideas and ask questions about any issues. The designer should be present as much as possible to help answer any queries.

Likewise, there’s an element of independent crocheting as well. If you feel strongly that you can complete a test without needing your hand held throughout, then fabulous.

A Keen Eye & Attention to Detail

Whilst you should not be expected to tech edit during a pattern test, attention to detail is still an essential skill. The odd typo could still be lingering, or perhaps the designer has made a tweak since the tech edit that wasn’t updated correctly. These things happen, and pointing out errors is hugely appreciated. You’re not just helping the designer but all the makers that come after you.

Making Pattern Changes?

If there is something in the pattern you’re not keen on? Ask the designer if it’s OK to change it a little bit. It won’t always be possible, as the designer probably wants to know how the pattern will work up as written. But there will be occasions when it’s not such a big deal. Don’t be afraid to ask.

Providing Constructive Feedback

Being brief with your words at the feedback stage kind of defeats the point of testing. I mean, you don’t have to provide a huge tome of opinions; rather, a few overall thoughts about the pattern, plus measurements and yarn info, would be the bare minimum. If it’s a garment, the designer ideally needs a photo or two of it modelled so they can see if it is what they envisage.

You might be asked about your likes and dislikes about the pattern too. And any changes you made?

Good photography skills

Good photos aren’t just because a designer wants you to push your new FO on social media for pattern sales. Well, it shouldn’t be. Sure, it can be a perk, but good photos are crucial for two reasons.

One, they help other makers see what a garment looks like on all different bodies and show a maker various colour options.

Two, they help the designer see if the pattern looks right across all sizes. It is frustrating knowing someone has tested a pattern, said it’s fine, but the designer doesn’t actually know because they haven’t seen it. As a designer, I have asked for photos and sent reminders, but it’s a tricky one; I’m in no position to make demands for photos to be shared when it’s an unpaid gig.

Crochet designers definitely appreciate good photos shared on Ravelry, too.

Crochet Pattern Testing Tips for the Designer

By the time it’s at the testing stage, a lot of work has gone into a crochet pattern, sometimes months and months. Unless you can pay testers, that doesn’t really matter to anyone else, I’m afraid. You’re relying on the generosity and grace of your community. So the first tip is don’t take advantage, you do not have the upper hand. Even if you’re gifting free patterns as a form of payment, it doesn’t equate to hours of making, and you know it.

Be Clear With Test Info From the Beginning.

Collate as much info as possible before the test to share with anyone who may be interested. Provide information about sizing, gauge, yarn requirements, the lot. Be clear on yarn weights, does fibre content make a difference, or is it not an issue? Is it a secret test, or can makers share their excitement for their new WIP? When is the deadline?

Don’t forget to tell people which terminology you’re using, as you might sign up US testers who aren’t familiar with UK terms. I tend to add all of this at the top of the initial questionnaire I send out. People then know from the start what to expect.

Provided a Generous Deadline

Back in the old days, during crochet pattern testing, I would only give six weeks to make a whole cardigan! Oh dear, I thought six weeks was generous because I had managed to make a cardi in two weeks. It doesn’t mean everyone else can; people have other stuff going on in their lives. Larger sizes take more time, too. I had to learn to plan better.

A full garment with sleeves should probably be a minimum of ten weeks, ideally 12. Anticipate when that will be and plan your pattern launch around it. Think about when it’s seasonally appropriate so you’re not finishing a test for a woolly turtle neck jumper in the middle of summer.

Send a Finished Pattern

I have tested patterns that are supposed to have charts, and the chart isn’t ready. I have tested patterns, and the photos haven’t yet been added. Eek, it’s difficult, but if those things aren’t ready, your pattern isn’t ready to test. It isn’t fair to the maker if you’re not including everything.

Ensure the pattern is as close to how it’s supposed to look on publication. That’s only fair. And if it can’t be, please be clear and make sure folks are good with that.

Whilst we’re on the subject, I’m not a fan of sending a pattern section by section. Not only is it micromanaging more work for me, it also suggests there’s no trust involved. I don’t like that.

Be Open-Minded to Tester Feedback

It’s not always easy, but you need a thick skin to hear other people’s thoughts. I have been very lucky with my testing groups so far, and don’t recall any moment when I’ve felt hurt by any comments. Look at the bigger picture; feedback that is honest and constructive is invaluable, even if it’s worded bluntly. You will produce a better pattern if you listen to that feedback.

Do Not Charge Testers!!

This shouldn’t even be a discussion. Who are you to charge testers who can’t complete on time? I have seen discussions about charging for non-completion of a crochet pattern test. I don’t think this is fair. Luckily, I have never spoken to anyone who has experienced this, so maybe it’s a myth. Bet it isn’t, though.

And whilst we’re on the topic of ridiculous asks, an NDA for a pattern test? It’s a bit far-fetched, don’t you think?

Let The Ghosters Go

It’s not worth getting upset about the folks who ghost a pattern test. Oh, it stings for sure. I’ve been there many times, and as a result, I am learning to get over it. Just ensure you have chosen a couple more testers than you need. Ghosters aren’t your customers, so let it go.

Do You Need Testers Anymore?

This is an interesting one. With your tech-edited crochet pattern, does it even need to be tested!? There are some for and against arguments with this one. I still get anxious about my patterns and feel a lot more reassured when the more complex ones have been made by a lovely group of volunteers who have kindly given their time to crochet pattern testing.

However, the more experienced a designer becomes, the less of a need there is for testing. Apprehension has been nudged out of the way by acquired knowledge.

Crochet Pattern Testing: Final Thoughts

Hopefully, I have covered most elements of pattern testing for crochet. It’s quite a big topic when looking at it from both perspectives. But it is very important to explore this subject from the two angles because there is a lot of involvement from testers as well as designers

Ultimately, one of the key messages to take away from this is to remember that we’re all people doing what we love. Kindness comes from both directions in crochet pattern testing, and it makes me sad when I see folks on the internet arguing about it!

Whether you’re a tester or a designer, tell me about your crochet pattern testing experiences. Have I missed something crucial? Do you approach it from a different angle? Let me know in the comments.

Cheers. x